Chapter 131: Little Li Became Excited! +1+1+1, All Go In!

Did Yan Xiangshang not understand the meaning within Su Bai’s words?

He of course clearly understood what the meaning within these words was.

However…

These words he could not clarify and state directly, he needed to shift the topic.

Now the court hearing was being livestreamed.

The transmissibility of the internet was rapid, and a wrongful case had caused the life destiny of a prospective university student to undergo a huge turning point.

The topicality of this matter could be considered already fully elevated.

Those media outlets, smelling the scent, had already arrived…

At that time some explosive headlines would surge wildly onto the trending lists, and it would be impossible to handle them well even if one wanted to handle them.

Moreover what they said was still the truth, and you would have no way to refute it even if you wanted to refute it.

This was the most critical issue.

There were certain problems in the procedure of the DNA appraisal, he understood this, and he could only pretend not to understand.

And the other party’s question he had already responded to, no matter what, this issue for the moment was considered to have been glossed over, and it had to be glossed over.

Su Bai noticed the change in Yan Xiangshang’s facial expression, he of course clearly understood what the other party was thinking.

However.

The issue of the DNA appraisal report was an issue that could not be bypassed.

You wanted to bypass it?

How could it be that simple?

You wanted to bypass it and then bypass it, what did you take me to be?

Air…?

This thinking was too simple!

Not to mention him, even if an ordinary trial lawyer were placed in this powerful trial situation, he would also seize this point and continue to question it.

In Lin Haoxue’s case.

There were not few procedural violations, among them this DNA appraisal was the largest violation.

And it was also the most important argument point in this court hearing for determining not guilty and accusing the law enforcement side of having fault.

Su Bai once again launched an attack against Yan Xiangshang’s defense.

Su Bai slowly unfolded the DNA appraisal report and spoke: “Our side does not believe that there is any problem with this DNA report.”

“Rather we are questioning the legality of the source of this DNA appraisal report.”

“According to the statement of the accused side, the victim female’s fingernails retained Lin Haoxue’s DNA, and this was during the process in which Lin Haoxue implemented infringement, when the female carried out resistance and attacked Lin Haoxue.”

“Then may I ask the accused side, at that time when Lin Haoxue was implementing infringement, there should also have been DNA evidence left by the infringement correct?

This is a piece of evidence that is even more favorable!”

“However… the accused side at that time did not raise this point, and only relied on the DNA remaining in the fingernails as the primary evidence.”

“Our side does not know whether the law enforcement side forgot this most important evidence, or whether there was no such evidence at that time, regarding this point our side will not express a position first.”

“However this is a very important doubtful point.”

“In addition…”

“As previously stated, the accused side did not investigate and verify Lin Haoxue’s explanation regarding the source of the bloodstains, this point also contains doubtful issues.”

“I believe the accused side should be very clear regarding the normal procedure for these two points, because these are basic procedural process issues.”

“Since so many doubtful points have appeared, then our side has the right to have reasonable grounds to question whether this DNA report involved procedural fabrication and whether it constituted malicious accusation against Lin Haoxue.”

This attack was simple and clear, and the attacking force was strong.

The meaning contained within it was very obvious, that was if you could not produce evidence then I would consider that this was intentional false accusation.

Su Bai’s objective was also very simple…

This DNA appraisal report was a place that could not be bypassed, the more the other party did not allow him to mention it, the more it showed that the problem was greater.

He did not clearly know whether Yan Xiangshang could produce reasonable grounds.

However in this argument he had already won.

Because if the other party produced it then it could be used as a clue together with the logically inconsistent doubtful points within it to initiate supervisory investigation.

And to question that there had been major procedural violations at that time.

The investigation might implicate a large group of people.

If the other party could not produce it.

It would be even simpler.

Based on suspicion of suspected fabrication of evidence and major procedural errors leading to a wrongful case a supervisory investigation would be initiated.

Responsibility of all parties at that time would be pursued.

At that time…

It would likewise implicate a group of people.

To put it plainly.

This case was a wrongful case, regardless of how the other party argued, after winning the case a supervisory investigation would be initiated and a group of people would be implicated, only the basis of the charges and conditions would be different.

Unless the second instance were lost.

However relying solely on the point that the other party had procedural problems it would be impossible to lose!

After Su Bai finished stating.

Yan Xiangshang’s facial expression instantly changed, and for a moment he did not know how to respond.

However fortunately at this time, at the trial bench seat, Presiding Judge Wang Jianjun struck the gavel, which allowed Yan Xiangshang’s expression to relax.

Bang bang!

“Pause the argument of both parties.”

Wang Jianjun looked toward Lin Haoxue at the party seat.

At this time Lin Haoxue’s facial expression was filled with nervousness.

This court hearing for him was the key moment to change his destiny.

At eighteen years old he was falsely accused and entered prison, six years later there was renewed hope.

This court hearing was the turning point of his future life.

Regarding this court hearing, he extremely hoped to win the case and return himself innocence…

Facing Wang Jianjun suddenly placing his gaze on him, Lin Haoxue’s expression was extremely nervous…

After all…

Although he was now already in his twenties, when he had just entered prison and was examined he had only just reached adulthood not long before!

Wang Jianjun saw Lin Haoxue’s nervousness and spoke a sentence to comfort him: “The party does not need to be nervous. I am only asking you several questions.”

“You only need to answer truthfully and not answer falsely.”

After hearing these words, Lin Haoxue’s emotions calmed much more, and he nodded seriously: “Okay Presiding Judge.”

Wang Jianjun nodded and began to question.

“During the examination stage at that time did you inform the source of the bloodstains on your body, how did the source of the bloodstains on your body at that time arise, do you still remember clearly?”

Facing Wang Jianjun’s questioning.

Lin Haoxue hurriedly nodded, although this matter had already passed six years, he remembered it extremely clearly!

He would never possibly forget it!

Lin Haoxue spoke emotionally:

“Presiding Judge”

“I can confirm that I informed it during the examination stage at that time.”

“The source of the bloodstains on my body at that time came from when I went out to play and during playful fighting with my female classmate they were left.”

“Is there evidence?”

Wang Jianjun asked, at this time Su Bai beside him took over the words: “There is evidence Presiding Judge.”

“Our side communicated with that female classmate, the witness is unwilling to appear in court, but there is a recording.”

This had already been preparation that Su Bai completed in advance after reviewing the case file.

Su Bai handed the recording to the staff member beside him.

The staff member handed the evidence to Wang Jianjun.

After Wang Jianjun conducted a general confirmation of the content of the recording, he slightly nodded.

The content of this recording.

Relatively speaking was somewhat vague, that female classmate indicated that on the day they went out to play she indeed scratched Lin Haoxue, and she was willing to bear legal responsibility for her own words and actions.

However because too much time had passed she could not determine the position of the scratch, she vaguely remembered it was the position of the arm.

In the determination of the first instance.

Lin Haoxue during the process of implementing the crime had been scratched on the arm by the victim.

The two corresponded and could match.

Since there was strong evidence to prove this.

Then this court hearing had no suspense…

Only regarding the judgment this was somewhat troublesome.

However for him there was nothing major.

After Wang Jianjun confirmed this in his heart, he struck the gavel.

Bang bang!

“Do the accused side and the procuratorate still have anything to state?”

Kong Jiantu: the other side directly threw this evidence onto the face, what else is there to state…?

At this time making a statement would completely be seeking trouble for oneself…

At the same time.

Kong Jiantu also let out a long breath in his heart, silently reciting: fortunately fortunately…

After silently reciting he looked toward the presiding judge’s seat and slowly spoke:

“Presiding Judge, our side has nothing to state.”

Likewise.

Facing Wang Jianjun’s questioning, Yan Xiangshang found it difficult to speak.

He simply could not say anything…

Make a statement…?

What else was there to state?

If he continued to state, it might involve more and more matters, at present the other party had already produced substantive evidence.

As long as he made a statement, Su Bai would seize this one point and continue to question it, then at that time the trouble would become even greater…

The more that was said, the more loopholes there would be, and at that time the trouble would become even greater.

This point Yan Xiangshang clearly understood in his heart.

After remaining silent for several seconds, Yan Xiangshang slowly spoke: “Presiding Judge, our side has nothing to state.”

Bang bang!

“The procuratorate and the accused side have nothing to state or supplement, then the court is temporarily adjourned!”

“After adjournment for one hour.”

“After reconvening the court the trial will continue!”

Bang!

Accompanied by the fall of the gavel and the departure of the members of the collegial panel.

The adjournment stage was entered.

In the courtroom, Li Xuezhen blinked her clear eyes and looked excitedly at Su Bai with her small face: “Lawyer Su”

“Are we going to win this court hearing?”

Su Bai smiled and nodded: “At present it seems that if the other side cannot produce any favorable evidence then it should be like this.”

“Then there is no problem.”

Li Xuezhen silently recited in her heart.

Who else could win a case against Lawyer Su…?

Winning the case certainly had no major problem!

This court hearing, although she was an intern lawyer and could not litigate such a case, she could observe it!

Whether the advantage was on our side or on the other side she could see it!

The purpose of asking Su Bai was naturally also to confirm her own judgment!

Won the case… very pleased.

Achievement points +1

Oh not correct, it should be +1+1+1+1+1…

As for exactly how many were added, Little Li was not very clear.

Anyway it was +1+1+1… that was correct!

Compared with the litigation party’s seat, Yan Xiangshang at the accused side’s seat at this time felt extremely anxious in his heart.

This court hearing…

If he lost…

Then the matters he would face would become troublesome, his professional career might be ruined because of this court hearing.

And there were also a series of subsequent troublesome matters.

At this time Yan Xiangshang in his heart extremely regretted it, if he had known earlier he would not have accepted this case!

If he had not accepted it then nothing would have happened…

Now after accepting it, it had drawn out a large number of troublesome matters.

Yan Xiangshang forcibly suppressed his fluctuating emotions and allowed himself to calm down in order to respond to the litigation after the court reconvened.

At the same time.

Outside the courtroom, in the court hearing livestream, many fans discussed the argument between Su Bai and Yan Xiangshang just now.

Is there any expert who can explain? Regarding the argument between Lawyer Su and the other lawyer just now, why did they argue like that? Can someone explain clearly?

Ahem… regarding this matter please invite the expert below to answer.

Hahaha, inviting someone to answer is not as good as inviting Teacher Luo to answer, in any case Teacher Luo is a professional legal commentator, his explanation thinking must be much better than ours.

Yes yes yes… Teacher Luo, explain it for us, analyze it… I only felt Lawyer Su’s pressure was strong, but I do not understand what the legal basis of the point they argued was… what meaning there was in making such accusations… we do not understand…

Luo Daxiang looked at the content in the comment section, smiled, and then spoke:

“Since you want me to explain, then I will talk about my own understanding.”

“In this court hearing the litigation party, that is the side of Lawyer Su, applied to revoke the first instance judgment and to conduct a not guilty defense for his client Lin Haoxue.”

“To conduct a not guilty defense from life imprisonment, this point requires major evidence to prove.”

“According to the evidence of the first instance judgment, the DNA appraisal was used as the primary evidence source of the first instance judgment to sentence Lin Haoxue to life imprisonment.”

“The litigation party questioned that there were problems with the DNA appraisal and also questioned that there were problems with the procedural process of the law enforcement side, then this was equivalent to overturning the evidence of the first instance and overturning the accusation of the first instance.”

“The second instance judgment would also determine revocation of the first instance judgment and declare Lin Haoxue not guilty because of procedural violations of the law enforcement side and insufficient evidence.”

“This was the key point of the argument between both parties.”

After Luo Daxiang finished explaining the key point in this court hearing, voices appeared in the comment section.

Understood, understood, no wonder Lawyer Su kept saying to let the accused side present the procedural source of the DNA, I originally did not understand this very well, now I understand…

Understood, does this not mean that the accused side fabricated DNA evidence? Made false evidence correct? Only on the court hearing it cannot be expressed too strongly and prominently, but roughly it means this!

However… since the other side did this then they certainly did not leave evidence, if they did not leave evidence then how can it be proved?

If they did not leave evidence then how can it not be proved? Did you not see that evidence has already been presented to explain the source of the bloodstains?

It has already explained that the source of the bloodstains was not scratched by that victim female, then the original accusation that Lin Haoxue committed the crime and using DNA proof to determine Lin Haoxue guilty itself was wrong.

Because apart from the DNA inside the fingernails there was no DNA evidence left during infringement of the female.

In addition there was already evidence proving the source of the bloodstains on Lin Haoxue’s body at that time.

This from the side already proved that the DNA evidence proof at that time was fabricated.

However it cannot be determined in court that the DNA evidence proof was fabricated.

Then…?

That is correct, after the court hearing ends initiating supervisory investigation will be sufficient!!

Looking forward to what follows!!

A major wrongful case!

Damn! The life of an eighteen year old was ruined like this correct?

It should not only be ruined, I also heard that at the first instance the application was for the death penalty, this means it was not only that the life of an eighteen year old was ruined, it was that an eighteen year old almost disappeared!

Damn!! If the Supreme People’s Court had approved it at that time then it would absolutely…

Alright alright, stop discussing, after the court hearing ends push it onto the trending list!

Okay! It must be pushed onto the trending list! Otherwise if in the future everyone present encounters such a situation what should be done if there is no place to reason?

Yes yes yes! It must be pushed up, otherwise in the future everyone present will all be defendants!

Looking at the discussions of his fans in the comment section, Luo Daxiang smiled and did not say anything further.

Jiangdu.

After seeing the announcement of adjournment, Hu Yulong placed both hands on his head and forcefully scratched his head.

How could this court hearing be conducted into such a situation!

What was going on?!

Was it not guaranteed to him that this court hearing would not have any problems? Why had it still become like this now?!

Even he as a layperson could see that this court hearing might be lost.

Hu Yulong now only hoped that even if judgment were rendered then afterwards no excessively large disturbance would arise…

Otherwise…

After thinking of the consequences, Hu Yulong could not help but take a cold breath.

Hu…

Now he should first contact some people and ask about the situation.

Inside the court, in the collegial panel discussion room.

Wang Jianjun sat on the sofa, Zhou Yun and Zhu Chaoyang likewise sat on the sofa, after the three looked at each other.

Wang Jianjun spoke: “Regarding how this court hearing should be adjudicated, you two should not have any objections.”

Zhou Yun replied: “This case itself has certain procedural error problems, regarding how to adjudicate there is no problem, all the factual basis and evidence indicate that Lin Haoxue did not have criminal facts.”

“Even if there are doubtful points, without strong evidence then it is also suspicion leading to acquittal, avoiding the occurrence of wrongful cases.”

“Regarding the judgment I have no objections.”

Zhu Chaoyang: “Regarding the judgment of Lin Haoxue not guilty I also have no objections, however regarding the accusation of the litigation party toward the accused side, I think this needs more consideration, after all if adjudicated too heavily it will cause not very good influence.”

“Although the accused side has factual errors, we also need to pay attention to this correct…”

“If it causes some unnecessary influence… it is also a troublesome matter.”

Zhou Yun refuted: “I instead think adjudicate as it should be adjudicated, or it should even be adjudicated more heavily, otherwise if such cases frequently occur then it will be a very great blow to our credibility.”

“It will likewise cause very great and not good influence.”

Facing Zhou Yun’s refutation, Zhu Chaoyang slightly thought for several seconds and then remained silent and did not speak further.

The points he considered were different from Zhou Yun, but what Zhou Yun said also had certain reason.

However…

The decision making power was in Wang Jianjun’s hands…

Wang Jianjun drank a sip of water: “Alright… regarding this judgment I already have preparation in my mind…”

“After reconvening the court we will see…”

“After all the current situation has not yet completed the argument…”

“Mm.”

“Okay.”

Zhou Yun and Zhu Chaoyang each spoke.