Chapter 133: Submitting Supervisory Investigation

Court adjourned…

The judgment result was announced.

At the court hearing site, the moods of all parties were complex.

After being adjudged not guilty and released, Lin Haoxue solemnly bowed toward the collegiate bench members at the presiding judge’s seat in thanks:

“Thank you Presiding Judge, thank you the two judges.”

“Thank you… thank you…”

“…”

Lin Haoxue stood at the party’s seat, his eyes red with excitement and his voice hoarse.

At the trial bench seat, Wang Jianjun smiled as he looked toward Lin Haoxue:

“There is no need to thank me… you were originally not guilty… the law only returned justice to you, adjudging this result was only natural.”

Facing Wang Jianjun’s words, Lin Haoxue nodded heavily.

Looking at Lin Haoxue, Wang Jianjun also silently thought in his heart that this justice had only come somewhat late.

As a vice president of the court, and having presided over many judgments, he had seen many special cases in criminal judgments, and also wrongful cases.

However, wrongful cases with such major injustice as Lin Haoxue’s were also very rarely seen.

And those that had almost wrongfully caused death were even more rarely seen.

After adjudicating this case, this judgment document and this case might possibly be submitted among the nation’s excellent cases.

Regarding the mood of the party concerned, Wang Jianjun was able to understand it.

He again looked at Lin Haoxue once, and Wang Jianjun instructed one sentence:

“First reunite well with your family, the subsequent court procedural formalities may be handled later.”

After speaking, Wang Jianjun finished arranging the court hearing materials and together with Zhou Yun and Zhu Chaoyang the two judges left the court hearing site.

Li Xiangfang quickly ran from the family seat to Lin Haoxue’s front, her eyes red, both hands tightly placed on Lin Haoxue’s shoulders.

Lin Haoxue deliberately spoke with a relaxed smile: “Mom, I am fine now, I have been declared not guilty and released.”

Facing her son who had unjustly sat in prison for so many years, and she herself having rushed about for so many years wanting the law to return justice to her son, now finally there was a result.

Li Xiangfang’s mood at this time was difficult to express, and she directly cried loudly in court.

“Good good good… now being fine is good, being fine is good…”

“Mom… I am fine now, I have already been declared not guilty and released… fine now… your son I will be able to accompany you well in the future, these years you have worked hard…”

Lin Haoxue’s eyes were red, thinking of the grievances of these several years, and Li Xiangfang persisting in running about for him, every time coming to visit him her son, encouraging him, letting him persist well.

Finally… justice arrived after six years.

Affected by Li Xiangfang’s emotional loud crying in court, he also could not help but burst into loud crying.

The mother and son tightly embraced, releasing the emotions in their hearts.

At the court hearing, the people who noticed this scene all remained silent without speaking.

After quite a while…

Li Xuezhen then seriously spoke with her small face: “Lawyer Su…”

“In law it is required that those who have committed major crimes must also have defense lawyers, this point I could understand before, but today I only completely understood it…”

Hearing Li Xuezhen’s words, Su Bai let out a long breath.

This case was a major wrongful case.

In law it is required that criminals must also have defense lawyers, the purpose of this point lies precisely in avoiding the occurrence of major wrongful cases.

Let everyone be able to enjoy the rights of legal obligations.

Within a reasonable scope, how it should be adjudged is adjudged.

Su Bai spoke: “Understanding it is good…”

At this time Li Xuezhen again asked one sentence: “Lawyer Su, previously you said whether delayed justice is still justice…”

“Lawyer Su do you think delayed justice is still justice…?”

Facing this question, Su Bai took a deep breath:

“This question is too subjective, as lawyers we cannot answer such a subjective question, but having an answer in the heart is enough.”

“Oh.”

“Okay Lawyer Su, I understand.”

“Pack up the materials and prepare to leave…”

“Okay Lawyer Su.”

Li Xuezhen simply arranged the court hearing materials once, and followed behind Su Bai with da da da steps.

At this time, Li Xiangfang and Lin Haoxue had also released their emotions, and quickly came before Su Bai.

They were very clear in their hearts that if not for Su Bai this time, what the court hearing situation would have been like was still uncertain.

For them, Su Bai could be regarded as their benefactor.

“Lawyer Su, this time regarding the court hearing I must thank you…”

“Haoxue, quickly thank Lawyer Su…”

“Thank you Lawyer Su…”

Lin Haoxue deeply bowed ninety degrees.

Su Bai smiled and supported Lin Haoxue to stand up: “Alright, words of thanks do not need to be said more…”

“There are still many matters to be handled afterwards, it is not that after the court hearing ends this case ends.”

Additionally.

Kong Jiantu and Yan Xiangshang after hearing this sentence each had different reactions.

Kong Jiantu: there is big news to watch in the Jiangdu public security procuratorate and court circle.

Yan Xiangshang: finished finished… it is considered completely finished…

At the same time, after the court hearing ended, the livestream audience comments also reached a climax.

Finished… this case can be considered to have welcomed a satisfactory ending, the party concerned was declared not guilty, it is only a pity for six years of time, if these six years had not been spent in prison, now there should have been a good life.

Satisfactory? In my view it is not satisfactory at all, this case originally should have adjudged him not guilty, he should not even have been considered a criminal suspect, he was still the person who reported the case, according to reason there should at least have been a reward for discovering and reporting, but he served six years in prison.

This case originally he had no problem, how are these six years compensated? I think those who handled this case at that time should all be arrested, and compensation should be given to him, only then can it be considered barely acceptable!

Yes! I feel what the person above said is very reasonable, those who did wrong at that time must all be investigated once, all arrested only then can it be considered some comfort for him having unjustly served six years in prison!

That is correct! I also think it should be handled this way, otherwise why should he unjustly serve so many years in prison, and almost be sent to the death penalty? Moreover if he had really been sent to the death penalty then what would be said? Would he not have died unjustly!

Yes!!! Support support!!

Looking at the comments in the comment section, Luo Daxiang smiled.

Regarding this case, after watching the court hearing livestream, Luo Daxiang already had a general judgment and understanding.

It was a wrongful case that was correct, the second instance adjudication was reasonable.

Mainly it was that the first instance judgment was very unreasonable.

Regarding the unreasonableness of this judgment, Luo Daxiang personally believed the error point might lie with the law enforcement side and the procuratorial side.

Because one included confirming and providing evidence, and one included confirming evidence and initiating public prosecution.

The most key point of this case lay in the evidence aspect.

As for the adjudication side, although it also had certain responsibility for verifying evidence, if the other two sides had truly intentionally concealed matters.

Then for the adjudication side it would at most count as a punishment for dereliction of duty.

There would not be any other impact.

However how to say…

Regarding what exactly happened in this matter, through the court hearing livestream it could not be judged.

It was necessary to wait until supervisory investigation and its adjudication in order to reach the final conclusion.

Everything now was based on personal subjective intention and was only speculation.

Luo Daxiang also found it inconvenient to express any opinion regarding this matter, therefore he smiled and spoke:

“Regarding the subsequent developments of this case, I will continue to follow it.”

“After obtaining first hand information, I will inform everyone through video.”

“The court hearing up to here can be considered finished, today’s legal commentary work has also already been completed, next I will take this court hearing as a typical wrongful case example and post it into short video, if everyone is interested you may look at the later specific interpretation of the case.”

“Alright… the court hearing is finished, the livestream is also finished, everyone goodbye.”

Teacher Luo goodbye… we are waiting for you to publish the video, then push it onto the trending list, to see what exactly the result is…

We must persist in the fairness of court hearings!!

Okay Teacher Luo! Following your subsequent specific interpretation!

Goodbye goodbye…

Amid the farewells of the fans, Luo Daxiang closed the livestream and smiled while shaking his head.

At the same time.

Jiangdu, within a certain residential community.

After seeing the court hearing judgment announced, Hu Yulong’s entire person tightly furrowed his brows.

During the court hearing livestream process, he had already anticipated that this case very possibly would lose.

If it lost, then for him there would be very serious consequences.

Wanting to rely on Yan Xiangshang to win the case in court was already impossible.

Therefore he telephoned some people and made preparations.

After seeing the court hearing result, Hu Yulong’s heart produced a sigh of indeed so.

The same as his judgment, in this court hearing Yan Xiangshang lost.

However for some reason, his heart now still had some agitation, worrying that this matter would continue to expand influence and produce not very good matters.

But the facts proved that Hu Yulong’s judgment ability was correct.

By late night toward dawn, Luo Daxiang combined the livestream court hearing content together with his own explanation and published it onto the short video platform.

Wrongful cases, especially major wrongful cases, generally were key concerns of relevant legal practitioners, the legal circle, legal institutions, and ordinary people.

Because no one could guarantee whether a wrongful case would fall upon their own head.

Moreover the formation of wrongful cases in essence was disrespect toward the law and violation of procedural rules.

Therefore after Luo Daxiang published the livestream court hearing content onto the short video platform, it caused enormous discussion.

Public opinion volume was very large.

And various media, after learning of this wrongful case, came upon smelling the news, all wanting to attract a wave of traffic.

By the next day at noon, the total network forwarding and total network playback volume of the case had already reached seventy million person times.

And it was still increasing at a very rapid speed.

Baijun law Firm.

Inside the office.

Su Bai sat on the sofa, Li Xuezhen sat on his left side, opposite were Lin Haoxue and Li Xiangfang.

“Lawyer Su… regarding this court hearing we must still thank Lawyer Su more, the relevant lawyer fees and litigation fees I have already according to the previous procedure transferred into the Baijun law Firm account…”

“Previously the child’s father left a sum of property, I have not spent it, Lawyer Su does not need to worry about our finances…”

Li Xiangfang spoke.

Su Bai smiled and nodded: “For the court judgment document I filled in your address, when the time comes you remember to sign for it and keep it well, when applying for state compensation, the various materials needed I have already prepared.”

Su Bai took out a stack of materials from inside the office desk and handed them to Li Xiangfang, and continued speaking:

“The subsequent content will have other lawyers of our law firm follow up.”

“If you think there is any problem, you may also contact me to resolve it.”

“However…”

“These are all normal procedures after the court hearing, but there is still one point that needs to seek your opinions…”

“Lawyer Su, you speak… seek our opinions on what, we all agree.”

Li Xiangfang regarding Su Bai allowing Lin Haoxue to be adjudged not guilty in court was very grateful.

Therefore regarding seeking opinions raised by Su Bai she directly agreed without thinking.

Su Bai smiled and spoke: “First do not agree so quickly, the matter is like this…”

“Your case clearly belongs to a wrongful case and may be submitted for supervisory investigation.”

“To speak plainly it is to investigate the problems of the personnel who adjudicated your case at that time, including the three departments of public security procuratorate and court.”

“Regarding this point, my opinion is to conduct supervisory investigation and pursue the responsibility of the relevant persons at that time, however regarding this point it still needs to seek your consent, I do not know what your views are…”

After hearing Su Bai’s words, Lin Haoxue’s eyes lit up: “Lawyer Su, can the relevant responsible persons at that time really be investigated?”

Su Bai smiled: “The current legal system is still very sound, regarding past wrongful cases investigation may be conducted.”

“As long as corresponding evidence can be provided it is sufficient, this case clearly has conclusive evidence proving it is a wrongful case, submitting investigation will not have too big a problem.”

“Lawyer Su! I want to initiate supervisory investigation, I want those who adjudged me at that time and let me unjustly serve six years in prison to pay the responsibility price they should pay!”

“Mm! Since you agree then there is no problem.”

Su Bai smiled and nodded.

After this case ended, the most important point also lay precisely in this supervisory investigation.

The relevant evidence certification materials he had already prepared completely and could be submitted for supervisory investigation at any time.

However six years of time had already passed, having evidence, submitting supervisory investigation had no problem at all.

But wanting to investigate out certain situations still had certain difficulty.

Because… six years of time, it could not be guaranteed where relevant clues had broken.

However… this matter raised enormous public opinion on the internet, the relevant departments certainly would accelerate this process and speed.

Moreover…

Relevant investigation personnel regarding this kind of situation were not unfamiliar, case handling ability and case handling speed were already very clear.

If strength was increased, it was estimated that not long would be needed to investigate out results.

Overall speaking the problem should not be big…